What to look at when marking history paper 2

When marking a History Paper 2, here are the key aspects to look at:

1. Understanding of the Question:

   • Did the student directly answer the question asked?
   • Did they address all parts of the question, especially if it was multi-faceted?

2. Historical Knowledge and Accuracy:

   • Is the information provided factually correct?
   • Are key dates, names, events, and concepts accurate?
   • Is there sufficient breadth and depth of relevant historical knowledge demonstrated?

3. Analysis and Interpretation:

   • Does the student go beyond simply describing events?
   • Do they analyze causes, consequences, significance, or comparisons?
   • Do they offer an interpretation of the historical evidence or events?

4. Use of Evidence:

   • Are specific historical examples, facts, or evidence used to support claims and arguments?
   • Is the evidence relevant to the point being made?
   • If sources were provided, how effectively were they used and evaluated?

5. Structure and Organisation:

   • Is the essay logically structured with a clear introduction, body paragraphs, and conclusion?
   • Are the arguments presented in a coherent and easy-to-follow manner?
   • Are paragraphs focused on a single idea or theme?

6. Argumentation and Critical Thinking:

   • Is there a clear line of argument or thesis throughout the essay?
   • Does the student demonstrate critical thinking by considering different perspectives, evaluating evidence, or acknowledging complexities?

7. Language and Presentation:

   • Is the language clear, precise, and appropriate for historical writing?
   • Are there significant errors in grammar, spelling, or punctuation that impede understanding?
   • Is the essay legible and well-presented?