While on duty at 3:40 one afternoon, you notice that an exterior door in a storage room is slightly open. You know that the door opens into an alley and is almost never used. Although the door is designated an "emergency exit," the alarm did not sound whenever the door was opened. You look out into the alley and see two small boxes, a few feet from the door, stacked between a trash dumpster and the wall of the building. The top box appears to be unopened, since the strapping tape is not cut. While you are standing by the door, an employee comes around the corner with a new unopened set of hand tools under one arm. Do you have reasonable suspicion to stop the individual and investigate? Explain your answer 8. Should vou arrest the individual? Explain your answer.

Question 1: Do you have reasonable suspicion to stop the individual and investigate? Explain your answer.

Yes, you have reasonable suspicion to stop the individual and investigate. Reasonable suspicion is a lower legal standard than probable cause, requiring specific, articulable facts that, when combined with rational inferences, suggest criminal activity may be afoot. In this scenario, the combination of an unusual open emergency exit door (which should have an alarm but didn't sound), the presence of suspicious boxes in the alley near the door, and an employee appearing immediately afterward with new, unopened hand tools creates a reasonable basis to suspect that unauthorized activity, potentially theft, has occurred or is occurring. These facts are more than a mere hunch and warrant a brief investigatory stop to clarify the situation.

---

Question 2: Should you arrest the individual? Explain your answer.

No, you should not arrest the individual at this stage. Arrest requires probable cause, which is a higher legal standard than reasonable suspicion. Probable cause exists when there are sufficient facts and circumstances to lead a reasonable person to believe that a crime has been committed and that the person to be arrested committed it. While there is reasonable suspicion to stop and investigate, the current information does not provide probable cause for an arrest. You do not yet know if the boxes in the alley are stolen property, if the hand tools the employee is carrying belong to the company and were stolen, or if the employee has a legitimate reason for possessing them and for the door being open. Further investigation, such as questioning the employee, checking inventory, or reviewing security footage, would be necessary to establish probable cause for an arrest.