Read the following scenarios and discuss the values held by the different participants. Can you see any conflict between values and behavior? Scenario 1:Every morning the participants commenced their five day workshop with fifteen minutes or more of prayer. On two evenings of workshop, hotel management was called to the room of some of the male participants. Complaints have been made about loud, aggressive behaviour and the use of obscene language. The men,all married were found to have a supply of alcohol and prostitutes in their rooms... Scenario 2. Each semester experienced male and female teachers come to Port Moresby to pursue their studies. The men are free to come and go as they please, the women are locked in their dormitories by 10pm.One weekend a group of female teachers decided to have an evening out. They made arrangements to stay in a hotel because they would not be back by 10pm.They enjoyed their dinner and were listening to music and dancing when they were approached by a group of men from the same course. The men were drunk and would not leave the women alone. The women fled to their rooms. The men banged on their door and use obscene language until they were chased away by the management. On Monday at Assembly the woman were ashamed in front of the whole college, accused of entertaining men, suspended from classes and told to write to their husband's.Nothing happened to men.
This psychology problem is solved step by step below, with detailed explanations to help you understand the method and arrive at the correct answer.
ScanSolve AI Answer
Here's an analysis of the values and behaviors in each scenario:
Scenario 1:
The male participants demonstrate a stated value of religious devotion and spirituality through their morning prayers. However, their behavior of loud, aggressive conduct, use of obscene language, alcohol consumption, and engaging prostitutes directly conflicts with these stated values. Their actions suggest a lack of personal discipline, respect for others, and marital fidelity, which are typically associated with the values they outwardly express through prayer.
Scenario 2:
This scenario highlights a significant conflict in values and a clear double standard within the college environment.
College Management's Values: The college management appears to hold values that prioritize strict control over female students, enforce traditional gender roles, and maintain a public image, even at the expense of fairness. They value the freedom and autonomy of men while restricting women.
Female Teachers' Values: The female teachers value personal freedom, social interaction, and the right to make their own choices, as evidenced by their decision to go out and make arrangements for their stay.
Male Teachers' Values: The male teachers' behavior suggests a disregard for respect, boundaries, and appropriate conduct. Their actions imply a value of male privilege and a lack of accountability.
Conflict between Values and Behavior:
The college management's behavior of punishing the women while taking no action against the men demonstrates a severe conflict* with any implied values of fairness, equality, or protecting students from harassment. They punish the victims for being out, effectively blaming them for the men's misconduct.
The male teachers' behavior of harassment and aggression directly conflicts* with any expected values of professionalism, respect, or responsible conduct for educators.
The women's desire for a normal social life conflicts* with the college's restrictive and discriminatory rules, which are not applied equally to male students.